Art Market Exposed: Hezbollah Sanctions Case Reveals Vulnerabilities

Art Market Exposed: Hezbollah Sanctions Case Reveals Vulnerabilities


Earlier this year, a Lebanese art collector was accused⁣ of money laundering ‍and⁣ violating terrorism-related​ sanctions in a federal indictment that focused attention⁢ on the reported beneficiary ⁢of some of his activities:​ the militant ​group Hezbollah.

The‍ collector,⁤ Nazem Ahmad, had been⁢ identified⁣ by U.S. authorities as a ⁤top financier of Hezbollah, the Lebanon-based ‌group that the U.S. government has designated a terrorist organization. The indictment, in April,‌ charged Mr. Ahmad with evading U.S. sanctions imposed on ⁣him in⁢ 2019, by using a network of businesses to conceal millions of⁣ dollars in transactions involving art and diamonds. Eight others ⁣were also charged.

The indictment led to ⁢headlines around the world. But‍ less discussed has been the extent to which it detailed, with example after example, how the art ​market ⁢had,⁣ by the government’s accounting, played a significant role ⁣in⁢ Mr. ⁢Ahmad’s scheme.

More than a dozen ‍galleries and artists had abetted what investigators characterized as Mr. Ahmad’s ​evasive tactics,‌ the indictment ⁣asserted. Though the ‍galleries or artists​ were not charged with wrongdoing, or accused of having knowingly​ helped Mr. Ahmad, ⁤the indictment depicted the art market as a ready ⁤vehicle for money laundering and sanctions evasion.

For example, more than a‌ year⁢ after ‍Mr. Ahmad had been identified as a financial resource for Hezbollah, ⁤and business with him‌ or entities he ‍controlled had ‍been banned,⁣ a New York ‌artist agreed, apparently‍ unwittingly, to ⁣sell him artwork, according to the indictment. The government said ‍Mr. Ahmad asked the artist, who was not named in the indictment,​ not to⁣ mention his name to the artist’s gallery ​because he preferred to remain anonymous.⁢ In 2021, the gallery, also unnamed, sold⁢ six of that artist’s works to a “Sierra Leone-based⁢ entity” described ‌by investigators as a‌ front for Mr. Ahmad, according to the‌ indictment.

The‍ Justice‌ Department included a series of images in its ‍indictment, including this image of a ⁤painting. The court papers said ‌ Mr. Ahmad had contacted a Chicago ‍gallery ​to commission it and several artworks by ⁤an artist based in ⁢the U.S. who was not named.Credit…Department​ of Justice

In another​ instance, the indictment said, an unnamed Chicago gallery sold 21 works to a company ‍that Mr.‍ Ahmad had⁣ long used to buy art.⁤ The March 2022 sale ⁤came more than two years after the ⁢sanctions were imposed prohibiting him‍ from such transactions. The shipment to a​ company in Lebanon was identified ⁣as containing “wooden baby cribs,” not works of art, the ‍legal documents said.

U.S. officials have said that Mr. Ahmad used​ his art to convert and shelter proceeds from his diamond trading, which‍ ultimately was a source of funding for Hezbollah.

“Since 2012, Nazem Said Ahmad has acquired over $54 million in ‌works of art from ‍major⁣ auction houses, galleries,⁤ and exhibitions, or even⁣ directly from artists’ ​studios, often concealing ‍his beneficial ownership by⁣ having official…

2023-09-01 14:38:30
Original from www.nytimes.com
rnrn

Exit mobile version