Oct twenty first 2021
SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS (SE) is a behemoth. The South Korean tech firm is the crown jewel of the mighty Samsung chaebol, because the nation’s conglomerates are recognized. It makes extra smartphones than some other firm on the earth, in addition to home-entertainment methods and home equipment. It dominates the manufacturing of reminiscence chips, that are used to retailer knowledge on digital units and whose value has been pushed up by the worldwide semiconductor scarcity. SE’s annual revenues of $200bn aren’t a lot decrease than these of Apple, essentially the most precious agency in historical past, and it’s sitting on a money pile of $100bn.
Listen to this story
Your browser doesn’t assist the <audio> ingredient.
Enjoy extra audio and podcasts on iOS or Android.
Now each SE and its mother or father group, whose identify means “three stars”, are getting into a crucial new chapter. In August Lee Jae-yong, the scion of the household which based Samsung in 1938, was launched from jail, the place he spent two stints after a conviction for his involvement in a bribery scandal. He is lastly taking full management of the empire from his late father, Lee Kun-hee, who died final yr. Succession was sophisticated first by the elder Lee’s six-year coma, then by his son’s bribery conviction, linked to SE’s efforts to win the federal government’s backing for a merger of two Samsung subsidiaries that will cement his management.
Free finally, Mr Lee has grand plans for the corporate, which he desires to turn out to be as dominant in cutting-edge logic chips, used for processing info, because it already is in reminiscence and smartphones. That will pit SE head-to-head with chipmaking powerhouses corresponding to TSMC of Taiwan and America’s Intel, and thrust it right into a fierce world contest over one of many world’s most strategic industries.
On October seventh SE confirmed it should manufacture a number of the world’s most superior logic microprocessors, primarily based on its novel “gate-all-around” structure with transistors measuring three nanometres (billionths of a metre), in 2022. It additionally stunned analysts by asserting a plan to mass-produce two-nanometre chips from 2025. It is forecast to speculate an eye-watering $37bn or so in capital expenditure throughout its companies this yr. And it’s profitable new clients, corresponding to Nvidia, an American chip designer, and Tesla, an electric-car maker.
The final result of Mr Lee’s gamble may have profound penalties—and never only for Samsung. It issues to South Korea, whose president justified Mr Lee’s parole as being within the nationwide curiosity, given the chaebol’s significance to the financial system. And it should affect the worldwide semiconductor trade, the crucial nature of which has been underscored by the worldwide chip scarcity. To guarantee success, the person whom acquaintances describe as shy, first rate and astute should additionally summon a level of ruthlessness.
SE is a fancy company creature with a strategic problem and underwhelming stockmarket efficiency. It is finest understood as divided into two principal companies. The first makes “sets”: smartphones, televisions and family home equipment. The second produces “components”, which go into Samsung’s personal units, in addition to being offered to exterior clients like Apple. Samsung splits its units enterprise additional into two divisions: TVs and home equipment corresponding to washing machines, and digital units (mainly smartphones). The part enterprise, in the meantime, includes semiconductors and shows.
The units enterprise just isn’t a development engine. In Mr Lee’s hierarchy of SE operations, say individuals near the corporate, house home equipment sit on the backside, beneath the TV unit with equally low margins however an even bigger position in reinforcing SE’s precious model. Next comes the handset enterprise, which within the early 2010s contributed over half of income. Although its obituary has been written a number of occasions earlier than, it continues to generate lots of money and, due to a brand new fast-selling vary of telephones with foldable screens, some recent optimism.
Atop the hierarchy sit semiconductors. Historically, SE has centered on reminiscence chips, the place it has 44% of the worldwide marketplace for DRAM chips (used for short-term storage in desktops) and 36% in NAND units (used for everlasting storage in mobiles). The reminiscence enterprise brings in simply over 20% of revenues however practically half of working income (see chart 1). Everything else is probably expendable within the service of its juicy margins. If a “set” enterprise has a disagreement with a parts unit over pricing or different phrases, insiders say, the part enterprise takes priority. According to the corporate, its distinctive ecosystem advantages from having numerous companies which permit inner innovation whereas offering stability by way of the ups and downs of trade cycles.
Late-onset reminiscence loss
Analysts reckon that SE’s memory-making has loads of life left in it. Because such chips are crucial for storing knowledge throughout industries, it’s “only going in one direction: up”, says Nicolas Gaudois of UBS, a financial institution. Omdia, a analysis agency, predicts that the worldwide memory-chip market will broaden at double-digit charges every year between 2020 and 2025. It is now much less cyclical due to surging demand from knowledge centres and, on the availability facet, consolidation within the trade the place ever extra excessive miniaturisation signifies that rivals can not step up manufacturing as simply as earlier than. SE says that it has confirmed a capability to innovate and extract worth in established companies. Internally, although, sure SE executives fear that reminiscence is a mature operation. And some buyers fret that demand for reminiscence chips could soften in direction of the top of the yr.
One choice can be to observe Apple and develop a companies enterprise, which has grown from 8% of the iPhone-maker’s revenues in 2012 to a fifth. However, regardless of just a few successes, notably in funds and well being apps, SE’s efforts so as to add software program and companies to its world-beating {hardware} have been sporadic.
This is partly as a result of SE’s hardware-first method is deeply rooted in its tradition. It will most likely be bolstered by Mr Lee’s character and expertise. “His disposition is very cautious and conservative, more so than his father,” says a former SE government. This innate conservatism could have been strengthened by his first massive endeavour after attending Harvard Business School. In the late Nineteen Nineties, on the peak of the dotcom bubble, he invested in eSamsung, a venture-capital agency. Watching the next bust left Mr Lee sceptical of Korean software program engineers, says the previous government; eSamsung was shut down.
Going massive on companies might additionally jeopardise SE’s long-standing and profitable partnerships with software program giants corresponding to Google and Microsoft. In 2014 SE launched a music-streaming service referred to as Milk Music, which regardless of its success was scrapped two years later. “Google viewed Samsung’s software efforts as fragmenting the Android ecosystem and felt threatened,” recollects a former government. “I feel pretty sure that Samsung has given up on software and services,” he sighs. He worries a couple of massive missed alternative. Even if the agency talks about making one other run at it, he provides, this is able to most likely be merely to maintain Google and different companions trustworthy.
Another downside is China. The nation is a vital supply of demand for each reminiscence and logic chips. To assist fulfill it, SE is ending its second memory-chip plant within the western metropolis of Xi’an this yr. Despite rising tensions between China and the West, specifically America, neither SE nor some other South Korean chipmaker is probably going to surrender on their large neighbour, which is prone to stay an enormous purchaser for a few years (particularly for the technically extra advanced DRAM chips). This signifies that SE should stroll a wonderful line to maintain Chinese shoppers whereas not relinquishing American clients.
This array of problems and dangers helps clarify SE’s underperformance relative to different giants, each in shopper know-how (Apple and Xiaomi of China) and chipmaking (TSMC and Intel). Because it combines a number of comparatively distinct companies, the corporate suffers from a conglomerate low cost. It is listed solely in Seoul, the place limits on publicity to particular person shares have previously pushed native buyers to promote SE, which accounts for practically a fifth of the KOSPI stockmarket index, every time its share value spiked. And SE’s huge money pile depresses returns.
As a outcome, regardless of stable working efficiency SE’s shares have traded between one and one-and-a-half occasions ahead guide worth, far beneath its friends. Increasing its dividend from 22% of internet revenue in 2018 to 78% in 2020 helped greater than double SE’s market worth within the two years to January. But Apple’s practically trebled in the identical interval. A robust outlook for semiconductors and decrease cyclicality in reminiscence chips have but to translate right into a richer valuation. Having surged by practically half in late 2020, SE’s market capitalisation has declined by 13% for the reason that begin of the yr, whereas New York’s tech-heavy NASDAQ index and a basket of world chipmakers have made features (see chart 2).
The logical transfer
Mr Lee’s guess on cutting-edge logic chips is designed to reverse the underperformance. The concept is to win an enormous slice of a fast-growing and profitable marketplace for non-memory chips, which account for 70% of the $550bn world semiconductor market. Mr Lee has set out a aim to match SE’s roughly 40% market share in reminiscence within the “foundry” enterprise of producing processors for patrons.
The Samsung scion has his work minimize out. SE’s foundry division took successful in 2016 when Apple moved all its enterprise for the A-series processor for the iPhone to TSMC. That shock supplied a stark instance of how SE’s advanced construction throws up attainable conflicts of curiosity with key clients. Half of SE’s foundry output goes to its units divisions, with the remainder supplying exterior clients. Apple most popular TSMC, a pure foundry agency, to SE, with which it competes in smartphones.
So far progress in direction of Mr Lee’s formidable goal, first signalled just a few years in the past, has been sluggish. The agency has round 15% of the foundry market, in contrast with greater than 50% for TSMC, which plans to spend $100bn over the subsequent three years on new capability. SE’s non-memory chip revenues make up solely 7% of complete gross sales (although that’s up from nothing in 2005 and the corporate additionally makes another specialised processors for sensors and the like). The share of income is even decrease.
Perceived conflicts of curiosity aren’t its solely problem. Although the reminiscence and logic companies share some commonalities and overheads, they differ in vital methods. Producing reminiscence chips is mainly about pace, quantity and economies of scale. Making high-end logic processors is way more advanced technologically, with engineering executed at nanoscopic scales and clients more and more needing silicon customised for his or her functions.
On know-how SE (and, to be truthful, nearly everybody else) has fallen behind TSMC in a minimum of the final two generations of cutting-edge processors. Part of which may be right down to wise warning. But reticence can additional complicate relations with clients, lots of that are reluctant to position orders until they will get capability ensures, says a semiconductor government at one other agency. Rather than anticipating their wants, SE has been reactive, says the chief.
Cognisant of those issues, Mr Lee clearly desires to speed up SE’s transformation. The firm is utilizing its research-and-development (R&D) prowess to take some dangers on next-generation logic chips, for instance with its new superior chip structure. The firm doesn’t escape how a lot of its capital spending goes to reminiscence chips and the way a lot to logic. According to CLSA, a dealer, there’s an emphasis on logic chips, that are additionally extra R&D intensive.
An increasing constellation
SE can also be mulling a $17bn manufacturing unit to fabricate cutting-edge logic chips in Texas, to appease America’s need to carry extra chipmaking again house from Asia (and, probably, to partake in a delayed $52bn subsidy splurge on the semiconductor trade that Congress is contemplating). And the brand new clients it’s courting, corresponding to Nvidia and Tesla, don’t have any overlap with its different companies, notes Sanjeev Rana of CLSA.
Help might come from the fraught geopolitics of semiconductors. Although rising technonationalism over chip design and manufacture makes governments favour home manufacturing and native champions, it could nonetheless find yourself benefiting SE. As China ratchets up navy strain on Taiwan, which it considers a part of its territory, fears are rising over TSMC’s future. According to a different semiconductor government, many corporations that use TSMC are scrambling to scale back publicity to the Taiwanese firm, simply in case. As TSMC’s closest rival, Samsung may very well be an enormous beneficiary. SE has the most important industrial advanced of semiconductor fabs and engineers on the earth, and a number of the finest chip know-how, says Mark Newman, a former Samsung group government who’s the chief industrial officer of Nyobolt, a battery startup.
One method to turbocharge the transition can be to separate SE into its constituent companies, as funding bankers have lengthy advisable. This would additionally get rid of the potential conflicts of curiosity which have hampered SE’s foundry division. A twin itemizing in America, in the meantime, might assist with the KOSPI-related drag.
Neither a break-up nor one other itemizing appears to be like probably, nonetheless. Mr Lee appears reluctant to countenance the unconventional first choice. One try at persuading SE into the second round 2016, as a part of an activist marketing campaign by Elliott Management, an American hedge fund which had taken a stake, failed. Aware of this, shareholders are due to this fact placing strain on SE to a minimum of do one thing about its unused money. One concept can be to pay out 100% of free cashflow to them. Alternatively, SE might do an enormous acquisition. The firm states that “the founding family is clearly aligned with all other shareholders in its objectives to create maximum value and see that value properly reflected in the market.”
To make a cloth distinction to SE’s monetary efficiency any deal must be massive. Mr Lee’s predisposition and preferences make such a chance unbelievable in software program and companies. That leaves chipmaking because the place the place the agency’s money may very well be spent. One potential takeover goal is NXP Semiconductors, a Dutch agency that specialises within the fast-growing marketplace for automotive chips. With a market worth of $50bn it will be a heavy raise, however not an unattainable one.
If Samsung Electronics is to turn out to be a logic-chip star to rival TSMC, Mr Lee had higher get lifting. Last yr he vowed to not hand administration of SE to his youngsters (although the Lees are prone to retain the most important stake within the firm by way of varied family-controlled automobiles). The promise to be the final Lee to run the agency, mixed with what insiders say are different enhancements to company governance, clears the trail to the highest for its multitude of gifted executives. They have to be hoping that Mr Lee leaves them a legacy that’s simpler than his father’s. ■
For extra skilled evaluation of the most important tales in economics, enterprise and markets, signal as much as Money Talks, our weekly publication.
An early model of this text was printed on-line on October seventeenth 2021
This article appeared within the Business part of the print version below the headline “The third star”