A gaping gap within the bony frill of a Triceratops dubbed “Big John” could also be a battle scar from one among his friends.
The frill that haloes the pinnacle of Triceratops is an iconic a part of its look. Equally iconic, not less than to paleontologists, are the holes that mar the headgear. For over a century, researchers have debated varied explanations for the holes, referred to as fenestrae — from battle scars to pure getting old processes. Now, a microscopic evaluation of Big John’s partially healed lesion means that it could possibly be a traumatic harm from a struggle with one other Triceratops, researchers report April 7 in Scientific Reports.
In summer season 2021, Flavio Bacchia, director of Zoic LLC in Trieste, Italy, was reconstructing the skeleton of Big John, the most important identified Triceratops to this point, when he observed a keyhole-shaped fenestra on the precise facet of its frill. Bacchia then reached out to Ruggero D’Anastasio, a paleopathologist on the “G. D’Annunzio” University of Chieti-Pescara in Italy who research accidents and ailments in historic human and different animal stays.
“When I saw, for the first time, the opening, I realized that there was something strange,” D’Anastasio says. In explicit, the irregular margins of the outlet had been odd. He had by no means seen something prefer it.
A pattern of bone taken from the border of a keyhole-shaped hole (circle) in Big John’s bony frill reveals proof of bone therapeutic, suggesting the outlet is a battle scar.Courtesy of A. Ferrara and I. Briano; R. D’Anastasio et al/Scientific Reports 2022
To analyze the fossilized tissues across the fenestra, he obtained a chunk of bone in regards to the measurement of a 9-volt battery, minimize from the underside of the keyhole. The remainder of Big John offered at an public sale for $7.7 million — the costliest non–Tyrannosaurus rex dinosaur fossil ever.
Looking on the bone below a scanning electron microscope, D’Anastasio and his workforce discovered proof per the formation processes of recent bone which can be often noticed in mammals. New bone development is usually supported by blood vessels, and within the bone close to the border of the outlet, the tissue was porous and strewn with vascular canals. Farther from the fenestra, the bone confirmed little proof of the vessels.
The workforce discovered that the irregularity of the outlet margins that D’Anastasio had noticed was additionally current on the microscopic stage. The border was dappled with microscopic dimples referred to as Howship lacunae, the place, in one of many first steps of bone therapeutic, bone cells eroded the present bone to get replaced with wholesome bone. The researchers additionally noticed main osteons, formations that happen throughout new bone development.
In addition, a chemical evaluation revealed excessive ranges of sulfur, indicative of proteins concerned in new bone formation. In mature bones, sulfur is current in solely low portions.
Sign Up For the Latest from Science News
Headlines and summaries of the newest Science News articles, delivered to your inbox
Thank you for signing up!
There was an issue signing you up.
Taken all collectively, it was clear that this explicit fenestra was {a partially} healed wound. “The presence of healing bone is typical of the response to a traumatic event,” D’Anastasio says.
Scientists can solely hypothesize what occurred so way back. But the placement and form of the wound counsel that Big John’s frill was impaled from behind by a Triceratops rival, including proof to the concept Triceratops fought with each other (SN: 1/27/09). It was in all probability an preliminary puncture that was pulled downward to create the keyhole form, the researchers say.
“Pathology is a great tool to understand the behavior of dinosaurs,” says Filippo Bertozzo, a dinosaur paleontologist on the Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences in Brussels who was not concerned within the research. Dinosaur habits has lengthy been within the realm of hypothesis, he says, however analyses like these can present a glimpse into the approach to life of those animals.
He provides that this explicit wound is “not a Rosetta stone,” as a result of it’s unlikely that each one fenestrae are battle accidents. “Fenestration is still a big mystery.”
What’s additionally a thriller, D’Anastasio says, is why the bone transforming seen on this Triceratops pattern was extra just like therapeutic noticed in mammals than in different dinosaurs. And Big John himself may maintain extra secrets and techniques.
“We published an aspect, a paleopathological case,” D’Anastasio says. “The complete skeleton of Big John must be studied.”